The Cold Plunge Controversy: Why Women Should Rethink Ice Baths

Cold plunges might be trending, but are they silently disrupting women’s hormones? 

While ice baths are hailed as the ultimate biohack for immunity, mood, and metabolism, most of the science behind these claims is based on men. Women’s cyclical biology tells a very different story—and ancient wisdom has warned about cold exposure for centuries. Here’s what every woman should know before taking the plunge.

Some have pointed to studies like this 2024 review published in GeroScience, which notes that cold-water exposure “spurs release of stress hormones, catecholamines and endorphins,” potentially enhancing alertness and elevating mood. Similar research suggests that cold therapy may activate brown fat metabolism and reduce inflammation. Small preliminary studies also indicate potential benefits for blood sugar and immune markers in extreme cold conditions. 

However, nearly all these studies are small, mixed, and often male-centric. 

Like so much of the scientific inquiry focused on men’s health, these trials fail to account for women’s menstrual cycles, resulting in questionable data when the results are applied universally. In practice, most of the purported “cold plunge benefits” come from general population trials — few of which have specifically measured women’s hormones. In other words, what works for generic healthy adults (and athletes) may not translate neatly to female biology.

 

Hormonal Hurdles: Cold Plunge vs Women’s Cycles

For most healthy individuals, a brief cold shower or polar dip is unlikely to cause harm. But women should balance the hype with caution. Health practitioners note that repeated exposure to freezing temperatures can significantly increase cortisol and adrenaline levels. In theory, those stress hormones could suppress progesterone (the “calming” hormone) and worsen PMS or menstrual symptoms, although direct evidence is scarce.

Anecdotally, many women report that ice baths feel invigorating, while others say they induce anxiety or cramps. But, it’s crucial to listen to your body and your cycle. If your period or mood symptoms are exacerbated by cold, then back off. Ice baths are not a one-size-fits-all tonic.

Luteal Phase (After Ovulation) – After ovulation, progesterone rises and raises your baseline core temperature by roughly 0.5–1°F [1]. You feel slightly warmer during the mid-luteal phase. This shift means your body will shiver sooner at a given cold. Practically speaking, long or very cold plunges tend to feel much harsher in the week before your period. 

A 2021 PET/CT study published in Molecular and Cellular Endocrinology found that women’s cold-induced thermogenesis (heat production) significantly declined during the luteal phase, reducing their ability to generate heat in response to cold. The researchers noted that this effect was absent in men, underscoring how female hormone fluctuations uniquely affect their cold tolerance during various phases of their menstrual cycles.

In other words, you lose your “female advantage” of generating heat from cold, so the chill hits you harder. For this reason, many clinicians advise women to skip intense cold sessions in the late luteal/menstrual week. It’s already a vulnerable time when the female body is working hard to regulate its temperature. 

Follicular Phase (Before Ovulation) – In contrast, the follicular phase (days 6–14 of the menstrual cycle) tends to be a “safer” window for short cold dips. Estrogen levels rise in the second week, which can enhance cold adaptation. The same 2021 PET/CT study also showed that premenopausal women exposed to cold had significantly more brown fat activation and energy burn than men under the same conditions. Women’s cold-induced calorie burn was strongly correlated with estradiol levels. In plain terms, around the time of ovulation, women appear to generate more body heat in response to cold stress than men do. 

So, if you want to try a brief plunge, mid-cycle might be the most forgiving time. Still, start with moderate temperatures (cold, but not freezing) and gradually increase the time spent in the water as your body allows. A few seconds is better than a sudden minute-long dive. Or, if you’re curious about cold therapy but aren't ready for a full-on plunge, try dipping your face in a bowl of ice water for 10-30 seconds. This simple alternative can help activate your vagus nerve, ease anxiety, and boost overall vitality without shocking your entire system all at once.

 

Safe Cold Exposure Guidelines for Women

Cold therapy doesn’t have to be all or nothing, but it does require a more informed, body-aware approach for women. If you choose to explore cold exposure, do so with respect for your natural hormonal rhythm and metabolic needs. Below are some tips for how women can do it safely.

Best time to plunge: The follicular phase (days 6–14 of your cycle) is when estrogen is rising and your body is more heat-efficient. This window supports better cold adaptation and a more effective metabolic response.

Avoid cold exposure during:

✗  Late luteal phase (the week before your period)
✗  Menstruation
✗  Postpartum period
✗  Times of illness, adrenal fatigue, or active fertility struggles

These are times when the body is already in a state of energetic output, inflammation, or hormonal sensitivity, all of which cold stress exacerbates.

Temperature: Begin with cool to moderately cold water (around 15–18°C / 59–64°F). For context, most commercial ice baths used in studies typically range from 10°C (50°F) to 0 °C (32°F). This temperature is quite intense and not recommended for beginners or hormonally sensitive individuals. Women don't need extreme cold to see benefits (nor do most men).

Time & Frequency:

⟳  Start small with just 15–30 seconds. Many of the vasoconstrictive and neurological effects of cold exposure occur quickly. Only increase duration if your body responds positively over time. Going longer doesn’t always mean better, and can often be counterproductive.

⟳  For most women, one to two times per week is sufficient. Frequent cold plunges can increase cortisol levels and disrupt hormone rhythms. Focus on consistency and gentle integration over intensity.

Always end with warmth: After any cold therapy (even short dips or contrast showers), wrap up with something warming, such as a hot shower, an infrared sauna session, herbal tea, or a warm foot soak. This practice encourages healthy blood flow and supports your body in returning to a parasympathetic (rest and digest) state.

Post-plunge check-in: Do you feel clear, calm, and recharged after your dip? Or anxious, depleted, and crampy? Cold exposure is a form of hormetic stress, meaning that the proper dose strengthens, but an excessive dose can have the opposite effect. Your body is always giving you feedback; your job is just to pay attention to it.

 

Ancient Wisdom on Cold, Heat & the Female Body

Long before the biohacking trends of cold plunges and ice baths took over TikTok, traditional medical systems around the world held a very different view on how women should engage with cold. From Ayurvedic to Chinese and Persian medicine, a striking throughline emerges: cold often does more harm than good, especially for the female reproductive system. These systems may differ in language and metaphysics, but their message is clear and consistent: The female body, particularly during menstruation, fertility windows, and menopause, thrives in warmth.

In Persian (Unani) medicine, the concept of the cold-warm dynamic is central to understanding the principles of health and wellness. Rooted in ancient Greek medical philosophy and refined by Persian and Arab scholars, such as Avicenna (Ibn Sina), Unani medicine places particular importance on mizaj (temperament). A uterus with a “cold temperament” (su’ mizaj barid) is thought to impair fertility, cause menstrual cramps, and slow blood flow. 

Persian traditional remedies emphasize warmth, utilizing warm oils, hot fomentations, heating foods, and avoiding cold exposure, particularly during menstruation. During the Islamic Golden Age, in his book, al-Hawi, al-Razi wrote: “If the uterus is affected by cold Mizaj (disease), then that closes the vessels, and the woman will become infertile.” [2] Medieval Persian texts recommend that in cases of reproductive coldness, warm oils, fomentations, and hot diets are beneficial, with herbs such as cinnamon and saffron often used to generate internal heat. Placing ice on the abdomen or plunging into cold water during key hormonal windows would most certainly have been seen by ancient healers as a direct threat to a woman’s vitality.

Ayurveda and Traditional Chinese Medicine echo the same sentiment—cold stagnates, warmth restores, especially for womb health and hormonal balance.


WILD SAFFRON SELECTIONS


 

Ayurvedic medicine shares a similar caution. In this tradition, menstruation is governed by Vata, the dosha associated with cold, dryness, and movement. When Vata is already elevated — as it naturally is during menstruation — adding more cold through ice baths, cold showers, or even chilled beverages can lead to uterine constriction, cramps, and fatigue. 

Ayurvedic practitioners have long prescribed gentle heat, warm sitz baths, sesame oil massage, and cooked, spiced foods to support the female body during this time. Modern Ayurvedic experts still warn that cold bathing during menstruation may aggravate suffering, especially when cramps and low energy are present.

In Traditional Chinese Medicine (TCM), the concept of a "cold womb" (宫寒, gōng hán) is a textbook diagnosis. Cold is believed to stagnate Qi and blood flow, particularly in the lower abdomen, leading to menstrual irregularities, cramps, infertility, or even miscarriages. Treatment protocols often focus on “warming the uterus” through moxibustion (burning mugwort near acupuncture points), the use of warming herbs like ginger and cinnamon, and lifestyle adjustments to avoid cold foods, going barefoot, or exposure to cold water. 

TCM practitioners explicitly advise against consuming cold drinks and engaging in cold bathing during menstruation or postpartum periods, noting that heat is necessary to restore balance and protect a woman’s Yang energy.

Despite these diverse cultural roots, the wisdom is surprisingly unified: Cold weakens, while warmth nourishes the female reproductive system. All of these systems warn that cold exposure can dysregulate hormones, restrict blood flow, and lead to pain or reproductive issues. It’s notable that the specific times when women today often turn to ice baths for mental resilience, during their period, while struggling with fertility, or entering perimenopause, are precisely the moments when ancient systems would recommend the opposite.

In a time when cold plunges are being marketed as a universal path to vitality, it’s worth asking: Universal for whom? Male-centered studies and physiology have shaped mainly the rise of cold therapy. Yet these centuries-old systems offer a counter-narrative, one that recognizes women’s cyclical bodies, and their deep, intrinsic need for warmth during key hormonal transitions. Persian medicine in particular, with its rich pharmacopeia and nuanced diagnostic framework, reminds us that, for internal balance, what cools one body may freeze another.


Soothing Alternatives to Cold Therapy

If you’re seeking relaxation and improved circulation but dread the shock of a cold plunge, there are time-tested, gentler, effective alternatives. A warm Epsom salt bath, for instance, has long been a go-to for soothing cramps, easing muscle tension, and calming the nervous system. Magnesium sulfate, the active ingredient in Epsom salts, may even be absorbed through the skin. A 2017 scholarly review published in Nutrients revealed that after a week of daily 50–55°C Epsom baths, all 19 volunteers except three had elevated blood magnesium levels. Even if absorption is modest, the warmth itself is healing, especially during menstruation or recovery.

Heat-based therapies, such as saunas or steam baths, are another excellent choice. Unlike cold plunges, which can spike cortisol, saunas increase circulation and promote a sense of calm. Research from large Finnish cohorts has demonstrated that people who use saunas 4–7 times per week experience a roughly 60% lower risk of stroke than those who sauna less frequently. Heat exposure raises heart rate and dilates blood vessels, providing a similar effect to light cardio. Regular sauna use is also associated with reduced pain and anxiety, improved mood, and better sleep. These benefits are especially valuable for women navigating hormonal shifts.

For those who enjoy a little contrast, alternating between hot and cold water rather than fully plunging into ice can offer similar circulatory benefits with less stress. In 2024, a clinical trial conducted by researchers in Japan found that after just 30 minutes of alternating hot and cold exposure, participants experienced significantly improved leg muscle oxygenation and blood volume. This “vascular workout” supports lymphatic drainage, reduces swelling, and may accelerate muscle recovery. The key is to end with heat so the body doesn’t remain in a cold-stressed state, especially for those with womb-centered or hormone-sensitive concerns.


Supportive Botanical Blends

Resilience comes from cultivating balance throughout your life, not just braving cold. A holistic approach can enhance stress management and promote hormonal balance. Adaptogenic and nervine herbs are a gentle way to regulate cortisol and soothe the nervous system. For example, ashwagandha, rhodiola, and holy basil help the body adapt to stress and support energy levels. Chamomile, lemon balm, magnesium, and other calming nutrients can improve sleep and mood stability. The effects of these plant-based supplements often resemble the adaptation benefits of cold exposure, but without the shock.

Some women find it helpful to use targeted herbal formulas alongside any cold therapy. For instance, if you’re noticing increased anxiety, poor sleep, or heightened sensitivity in the days after a cold plunge, your nervous system might be overstimulated. Inner Peace, our potent new saffron and lemon balm blend, was created to restore calm without sedation — especially during hormonal transitions. 

For those navigating womb-related symptoms like cramps or irregular cycles, Womb Whisperer offers ancient uterine tonics like vitex and shatavari that gently restore warmth, balance, and hormonal rhythm — the very wisdom cold plunges risk disrupting when mistimed. And if you're seeking immune resilience and better circulation without the cortisol spike, Resilient Body — our mushroom adaptogen blend — offers gentle ongoing support without the jolt of extreme cold. Specifically designed for individuals navigating autoimmune imbalances, this product features full-spectrum fruiting body extracts and tonics, including astragalus and codonopsis. Taken daily, it promotes balanced immune function, energy, and a more graceful aging process.

These wild blends exemplify a “nourish and warm” strategy. When used consistently, these botanicals can help regulate hormone rhythms, reduce cortisol spikes, and maintain a more balanced cycle. Think of them as “warm baths” for your insides, fostering more supportive routines for resilience day after day. Pairing these with gentle heat therapies and stress-reducing practices will likely have a more significant impact on your hormones than pushing yourself through repeated shivers.

Ultimately, when it comes to temperature therapy, women may benefit most from the “low and slow” approach. Cold plunges aren’t inherently bad, but their intensity isn’t always the best fit, particularly during menstruation, postpartum, or times of adrenal fatigue. If you do plunge, keep it brief and listen to your body. And when your system feels depleted or you're fighting illness, remember: that’s not the time to push limits — it’s the time to restore.

While cold plunges may boost alertness and offer mild metabolic or immune benefits in healthy individuals, it’s also worth noting that the evidence is largely generalized (usually from men), and women’s cyclical biology alters the picture. Late-cycle (high-progesterone) women tend to feel the cold much more intensely, while mid-cycle (high-estrogen) women may tolerate it better. 

Ancient medical traditions uniformly advise women to stay warm in menstruation and pregnancy. So, who do we believe: biohackers or over 5,000 years of ancestral wisdom?

Ultimately, we need to stop telling women to “tough it out” with ice and in life, and instead build whole-body resilience. If an icy dip invigorates you and you feel great afterward, go forth and plunge! But please remember there are many other ways to strengthen immunity, circulation, and mood that won’t risk hormonal imbalance. Whether it’s a refreshing cool shower on a hot day, a detoxifying sauna, or a cup of warm adaptogenic tea, choose what feels good intuitively. 

Want the cold, hard truth? Women aren’t meant to freeze their way through the healing process. From Persian to Chinese to Ayurvedic medicine traditions, the message is clear: warmth restores. Cyclical bodies need cyclical care. Women’s strength comes not from toughing it out and pushing through the cold, but from honoring their unique rhythms. Your body will never forget the wisdom that thousands of years of ancestral knowledge have imparted. Listen to her.

Read next: 

The Hidden Thyroid-Fertility Link: Why Your Hormones, Cycles, and Baby’s Health Depend on this Small but Mighty Gland

Why Your Grandma’s ‘Slow Living’ is Trending

 

Back to blog